Kelsen sets out his views in the first chapter of general theory of law and state, the first sentence states that law is an order of human behaviour which designates a specific technique of social organisation. May 27, 2018 hey legal eagles this vedio is related to hans kelsons pure theory of law. Kelsens pure theory of law kelsen intends his pure theory of law to serve as a general account of the nature and function of law. Kelsen s pure theory is about the hierarchy of norms. Kelsen lives european journal of international law. Whether x ought to be punished for committing murder of y or not is a norm. A look at the legality of military administrations in nigeria. Clark nphe publication in 196 7 of pure theory of law, a translation ofi the second 1960 german edition of hans kelsens reine rechtslehre, has largely escaped the notice of jurisprudential commentators. Kelson did not favour widening the scope of jurisprudence by co. I propose, therefore, to consider 1 the extent to which kelsens exposition of the naturallaw doc.
Hence, the theory is more so given in terms of formation of hierarchical laws commencing from basic norm. Rather, his aim was to present law as it is, free from all the various ideologies. Jan 29, 20 before entering into kelsen thesis on pure law theory, the researcher would like to put the differentiation between the natural law school and analytical positivism school. If, however, something called the naturallaw doctrine can be attributed to anyone, surely it can be attributed to aquinas. According to kelsen, the legal system must be pure that is, selfsupporting and not dependent on extralegal values. He does not want to include in his theory what ought to be but for him, law is a theory of analysis an analysis that is free from all ethical and political judgment of value salient features of kelson s pure theory of law essential of kelson s pure theory of law. Hans kelsen on international law francois rigaux abstract kelsens monistic theory of law, according to which international and municipal law have the same subjectmatter, paved the way for the dominant contemporary doctrine. Contribution of thetheory pure theory of law enriched jurisprudence. This is important because different disciplines have different methodology, and so its hard to analyse law when its all mixed up with other things.
Summary of hans kelsens pure theory of law hugh mccarthy. Hans kelsen, the theory of law and the international legal system. Law, morality, religion while recognizing law as the specific social technique of a coercive order, we can contrast it sharply with other social orders which pursue in part the same purposes as the law, but by quite different means. The theory is pure because it separates jurisprudence from other disciplines like ethics, politics and psychology. Kelsen began his long career as a legal theorist at the beginning of the 20th century. A landmark in the development of modern jurisprudence. Kelsons theory of pure science of law kelson was not in favour of widening the scope of jurisprudence by corelating it with other social sciences. Kelsen, hart, and legal normativity openedition journals. Although he was not of angloamerican birth, the idea of purity of his account of law, his views on legal structure and on the general form that all laws took, and his theory of legal validity, have contributed much to the theories of legal.
Kelsen studied law in vienna taking his doctorate in 1906 and later acted as a professor at the university of vienna. The pure theory of law stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The second aspect in kelsens theory is that the whole system is interconnected with each other in the form of a hierarchy of norms. The vedio conatins why it is called pure theory of law. It insists on a distinction between human law, which they call positive law and moral and scientific laws. Kelsens book contains only text neither logical notation nor pictures. Human laws are posits of human society while scientific laws are independent of what we take them to be. Hans kelsen was an austrian lawyer and philosopher. What are the mains points of criticism of this theory. Norms unlike facts focus on what ought to be and not what is. An analysis of the kelsons theory of law sk jahangir ali, assistant professor, balurghat law college,p. Kelsens pure theory of law 1 law is a normative science according to kelsen law is a normative science but law norms of science are norms of is sein means law norms may be distinguished from science norms on the ground that norms of.
Hence we may well begin by looking at greek law and greek definitions of law as determined thereby. Hey legal eagles this vedio is related to hans kelsons pure theory of law. He was a professor of law at the vienna university. The pure theory of law maintains that laws are norms handed down by the state. It is charged that kelsens theory is betrayed, on its own terms, if it is put to normative use as a practical principle for guiding judicial decision and action. Reprint of the second revised and enlarged edition, a complete revision of the first edition published in 1934. The law, kelsen maintained, is basically a scheme of interpretation.
Hans kelsen normative theory grundnorm jurisprudence. The segregation of morals and law by kelsen forms an essential. Oamritakhando hat,distddinajpur,pin733103 west bengal, india. Hans kelsen, the pure theory of law critique customwritings. Though the first exposition of theory took place in 1911, it came in full bloom in.
This paper deals with the basic causes of numerous often extremely negatively intoned critical estimations said on the account of kelson s pure theory of law and exposes essential properties of certain phases of its development. Positive law is a reaction against particularly that aspect of natural law theory. Kelsons comparision bw natural science and normative science. He does not want to include in his theory what ought to be but for him, law is a theory of analysis an analysis that is free from all ethical and political judgment of value salient features of kelsons pure theory of law. Continue reading hans kelsen normative theory grundnorm jurisprudence notes. The dynamic theory of law is the explicit and very acutely defined. By this he means that law is a mechanism for making people do things. The strength of pure theory of law lies in the provision of a theoretical law, which accommodates administrative and judicial tribunals along with legislative rigours of the legal system and administrative bodies. From an intrasystemic, internal, or legal point of view, law is norm, not fact. Though the first exposition of theory took place in 1911, it came in full bloom in postwar europe. The idea of a pure theory of law was propounded by the austrian jurist and philosopher hans kelsen. The pure theory of law which is also known as vienna school of legal thought was propounded by hans kelson, a professor in vienna austria university.
International law does not fit in the pure theory of law. A theory itself is an abstract idea that comes from a human mind. Instead, kelsen suggested a pure theory of law which would avoid reductionism of any kind. Kelsen is known for the most rigorous development of a positivist theory of law, i. For that reason, it should be taken as a limitation of the theory.
Kelsens theory of the basic norm joseph raz of all. And law is a means, a specific social means, not an end. This essay will set out to discuss the key role played by sanction in kelsens theory of law. The dynamic theory of law is singled out in this subsection discussing the political philosophy of hans kelsen for the very same reasons which kelsen applied in separating its explication from the discussion of the static theory of law within the pages of pure theory of law. Jurisprudence pure theory of law by hans kelsen part 2. Kelsen proffers a theory of law not a rule of decision. His pursuit of a science of law is premised upon the claim that an account of law can be disinfected. The pure theory of law is termed as theory of positive law. According to kelson law is a normative science and it is not a natural science based on cause and effect like law of gravitation.
The pure theory of law is only helpful to legal scientist. Vol 4 the western australian jurist 285 hans kelsens theory and the key to his normativist dimension kendra frew i introduction writers have both praised and criticised hans kelsens work, however all would agree that he is a theorist to be reckoned with. It attempts to answer the question what and how the law is, not how it ought to be. Before entering into kelsen thesis on pure law theory, the researcher would like to. Gt for the general theory of law and state new york. Instead, kelsen suggested a pure theory of law which would avoid reductionism. Hans kelsen, the theory of law and the international legal. Kelsen s pure theory allows for a pure legal science. In 1925 professor kelsen published his allgermeine saatslehre, summarizing in systematic form the contributions made. Reine rechtslehre is a book by legal theorist hans kelsen, first published in 1934 and in a greatly expanded second edition effectively a new book in 1960. Overview hans kelsen was an austrian legal theorist, who worked in germany until the rise of the nazi party, and then in the usa. There are familiar questions connected with explaining legal.
Kelsen studied law in vienna taking his doctorate in. Pdf hans kelsens pure theory of law is the most prominent and influential legal theory for continental law systems. He published the first edition of the pure theory of law in 1934, and a second, expanded edition which i read in 1960. The austrian philosopher and jurist named han kelsen proposed the pure theory of law. Part one surveys the fundamentals of kelsens argumentative strategy against natural law and its theorists. Hans kelsen pure theory of law introduction hans kelsen was born in prague on the 11th october 1881. The second edition appeared in english translation in 1967, as pure theory of law, the first edition in english translation in 1992, as introduction to the problems of legal theory. Hans kelsen was an austrian legal theorist, who worked in germany until the rise of the nazi party, and then in the usa.
This paper deals with the basic causes of numerous often extremely negatively intoned critical estimations said on the account of kelsons pure theory of law and exposes essential properties of certain phases of its development. Firstly, he rejected the idea of command, because it introduces a psychological element into a theory of law, which should, in his view, be pure. Pdf visualization of hans kelsens pure theory of law. Hans kelsen 18811973 austrian jurist and philosopher of law. Before entering into kelsen thesis on pure law theory, the researcher would like to put the differentiation between the natural law school and analytical positivism school. Dec 16, 2017 spread the lovenorms and facts facts consist of things and events in the physical world and revolve around what is.
Hart, and many other legal theorists of the past century1 is the idea that law is a normative system, and that any theory about the nature of law must focus on its normativity. Journal for constitutional theory and philosophy of. A landmark in the development of modern jurisprudence, the. Only if it is taken for granted that kelsen does not have a moral conception of the sanction qua necessary evil is it possible to understand how he could come to the conclusion, already in the first edition of his pure theory of law, that the law cannot be broken. Kelsen, an analytical jurist, in his pure theory of law says, law is the norm which stipulates sanction. Translation from the second german edition by max knight. With his pure theory of law, hans kelsen did not wish to present any new ideology of law. For kelsen law is the knowledge of hierarchy of normative relations. Kelson tried to rescue jurisprudence from vague mysticism and in a. Kelsens pure theory of law introduction generally, law is, a system of rules and regulations which are enforced through social institutions to govern human. Kelsens pure theory can be said to be one of the most refined developments of analytical. Kelson did not favour widening the scope of jurisprudence by corelating it with all social sciences and rigorously. Philosophical foundations of the pure theory of law. The first of these is the relation of law to theories of what the law should be, on the one hand, and to the institutions, practices and mores of its society, on the other.
The present paper purports to provide an analytical reconstruction and critical assessment of such a critique. The jurisprudence kelsen propounded characterizes itself as a pure theory of law because it aims at cognition focused on the law alone and this purity serves as its basic methodological principle pt1, 7. Greek law was built upon the small body of institutions common to. According to kelsons pure theory of law, it must be free from ethics, morality, politics sociology, history etc it must be pure. The code of the legal system, the formative distinction that creates and perpetuates the identity of the legal system is lawful. He also says about the normative behaviour which takes validity from the ground norm. The remainder of the norms are associated by inferior norms, when one is contrasted with another. The traditional legal philosophies at the time, were, kelsen claimed. Pdf hans kelsen pure theory of law majd rashyd academia.
The natural law school deals with the concept of law of nature. It also says about the value, ethics, morality and supernatural aspect. Hanno kaiser 2004 1 law and nature law and nature are categorically di. The greeks developed this body of institutions in such a way as to get from the stage of primitive. Hans kelson 18811973 introduction credit of reviving the original analytical legal thought in 20th century pure theory of law. In referring to kelsens books the following ab breviations are used. He insisted on separation of law from politics, sociology, metaphysics and all other extra legal disciplines. Pdf kelsens pure theory of law naveed hussain academia. Hans kelsens pure theory of law is the most prominent and influential legal theory for continental law systems. Or kelson wishes to free the law from the metaphysical mist which it has been covered of all times. The pure theory of law exists on a metallevel and intends to attain cognition. The idea of a pure theory of law was propounded by the formidable austrian jurist and philosopher hans kelsen 18811973 see the bibliographical note.
1161 923 373 1506 972 1210 462 892 256 29 621 785 972 1098 155 917 124 909 475 513 1250 379 1511 885 54 1063 1488 698 71 622 947 825 852 964 793 1079 490 829 1490 1313 965 476 773 16 745